ASTANA (TCA) — The year 2017 was marked in Kazakhstan by the authorities’ efforts to lay the ground for a smooth state power succession and to overcome the country’s economic and financial problems accumulated in the recent years. We are republishing this article by George Voloshin on the issue, originally published by The Jamestown Foundation’s Eurasia Daily Monitor:
BISHKEK (TCA) — The China-Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan railway route will be determined in April 2018, participants of the tripartite talks decided in Tashkent in late December. The meeting made decisions on the timing of the project, sources of financing and the development of its feasibility study.
BISHKEK (TCA) — 2017 was a remarkable year for Central Asia countries. In Kazakhstan, the economy has stabilized while the power succession issue remains relevant. Kyrgyzstan saw the first peaceful transfer of power in the October presidential election. In Tajikistan, President Rahmon continued the consolidation of his power, while Turkmenistan has experienced a dramatic economic downturn caused by lower natural-gas prices. In Uzbekistan, the new President has pursued reforms and undertaken efforts to improve his country’s relations with Central Asia neighbors. We are republishing this article by Paul Goble on the issue, originally published by The Jamestown Foundation’s Eurasia Daily Monitor:
BISHKEK (TCA) — Bishkek-Tashkent-Bishkek air flight has been resumed late in December 2017, to run twice a week. In early 2018, it is also planned to resume the Osh-Tashkent-Osh flight.
The agreement on the resumption of air communications between Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan was reached during the official visit of Kyrgyzstan President Sooronbai Jeenbekov to Tashkent in December.
To expand the geography of air flights, Kyrgyzstan needs to improve conditions for its aviation development.
It is a shame that the national airline company has only one plane, Prime Minister of Kyrgyzstan Sapar Isakov said recently at the Business Development and Investment Council meeting to discuss the country’s tourism development program.
According to Talgart Nurbayev, Director General of the state owned Air Manas airline, it is difficult for Kyrgyzstan to purchase aircraft through leasing because the country is blacklisted by the European Union. Staying on the EU blacklist increases leasing payments twice, he said.
To exit from the blacklist, Kyrgyzstan has to meet the requirements of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and IATA Operational Safety Audit (IOSA), which requires large financial costs.
Prime Minister Isakov believes that transition to the open skies policy is necessary for Kyrgyzstan, so that citizens could fly to distant countries directly and without extra costs.
By the end of 2018, all ICAO recommendations will be fully implemented and Kyrgyzstan will be able to apply for the lifting of the flight restrictions in Europe by the end of 2019, Director of the Civil Aviation Agency of Kyrgyzstan (CAA) Kurmanbek Akyshev said.
In December 2017, ICAO specialists checked the Manas International Airport (MIA), the country's airlines and the CAA. The ICAO experts' conclusions were much more positive than in previous years when two audits resulted in much criticism.
Kyrgyzstan's airlines have been on the European Union blacklist since 2006.
Passengers departing from Bishkek and Osh often have to travel to many foreign countries not directly but changing airlines, which is inconvenient and expensive.
For 26 years of independence, the state has not been able to fundamentally reform the aviation industry. The current airport management promised that with 8 billion soms of credit it would rectify the situation. But the loan would be a debt to be paid out by taxpayers. Even if the MIA receives this money, there is no guarantee that there will be a result and the quality of services will improve. Therefore, it would be better to assign this task on a reliable foreign investor.
The transfer of large airports to the trust management of a foreign company is a common international practice, and local citizens should not be afraid of this practice, the local business community says. In many countries, the state and private business work in partnership. The issue currently under discussion should be resolved within the public-private partnership. There are many companies in the world that have proven their professionalism, such as TAV from Turkey or companies from South Korea and Singapore.
Last November, Prime Minister Isakov met with Mustafa Sener, executive director of TAV Airports Holding, who said the holding, being among the leading airport operators in the world, had previously carried out large projects in Georgia and Macedonia. TAV Airports Holding is interested in investing in Kyrgyzstan, Sener said.
This issue was discussed in the Parliament of Kyrgyzstan.
“Kyrgyzstan is a landlocked country located in the mountains. For this reason, there are only two ways to go abroad — by air and by ground transport. So we need to develop aviation, and there is no other alternative,” Prime Minister Isakov said at the parliament.
Citizens of Kyrgyzstan should have a choice by which company to fly. “We fly to other countries through Moscow or Istanbul because we do not have a choice. I think this is wrong,” he said.
The State should review its civil aviation policy. “We should be realistic and understand that we will not be able to develop our airports ourselves,” Isakov said.
Many large companies are interested in Kyrgyzstan and TAV Airports Holding is among them. “We will definitely negotiate with them but it is MPs who will make a decision whether to give the MIA into the concession or not,” Prime Minister concluded.
The Investment Promotion and Protection Agency of Kyrgyzstan is studying the world experience in order to choose the model most acceptable for Kyrgyzstan. The Agency intends to select five large companies working in this field and hold a tender among them.
There are also discussions about the possible sale of a 79% state stake in the MIA JSC. The State Property Management Fund explained that the MIA will not be sold because it not only brings profit but also is a strategic facility.
‘No changes needed’
Some MPs and experts believe that nothing needs to be changed, and the Manas International Airport should continue to develop independently. The MIA is among the main taxpayers, paying at least 1.5 billion soms in dividends to the state budget annually. When the American airbase was leaving the MIA, many predicted that the airport would “wither” but thanks to the good management, it is among the main payers of dividends in the country. In addition, the MIA at its own expense began to reconstruct the airports in the country’s regions.
The international airport is a complex facility, where various bodies perform their functions, and the quality of passenger service depends on how well all these bodies interact, MIA Board Chairman Emir Chukuyev said. For instance, the State Border Service performs border control, and it depends on them whether passengers will pass border controls without delay.
Customs control is the competence of the State Customs Service. To meet international standards, it should create a so-called green corridor. The level of passenger service also depends on the airlines that perform flights. However, passengers used to blame the airport for all the inconveniences, Chukuyev said.
Over the past five years, the MIA has increased passenger traffic by 63%, the company said. The MIA includes 11 operating airports across Kyrgyzstan — five international and six regional ones.
According to the Kyrgyz CAA, 36 airlines are currently operating in Kyrgyzstan including 32 international and four domestic airlines.
The main obstacle to the development of the airport infrastructure is the Law on Public Procurement, experts say. Long bidding procedures and other legal complexities make the MIA not competitive even among the airports in Central Asia.
Tajikistan: searching for food security
Written by Irna Hofman
DUSHANBE (TCA) — For Tajikistan, diversification of agricultural crop production and shifting away from cotton monoculture is vital for improving the wellbeing of local farmers and achieving the country’s food security. We are republishing this article by Irna Hofman* on the issue, originally published by EurasiaNet.org:
BISHKEK (TCA) — The countries of Central Asia, especially Kazakhstan, may significantly benefit from China’s Belt and Road initiative aimed to create transport and transit routes from Asia to Europe. But such benefits may turn out to be not as big as expected. We are republishing this article by Nathan Hutson on the issue, originally published by EurasiaNet.org:
BISHKEK (TCA) — In the time of the Great Game, Afghanistan was in the center of the struggle between the Russian and British empires for their influence on Central Asia. Nowadays, post-Soviet republics of Central Asia seek to build stronger economic ties with their southern neighbor, as Afghanistan is a promising sales market and transit link for access to the Indian subcontinent and southern sea ports. This cannot be ignored by Russia and other world powers. In the following article, originally published by The National Interest, S. Frederick Starr* says that Afghanistan is part of Central Asia and not simply a problematic neighbor:
BISHKEK (TCA) — At the invitation of President of Uzbekistan Shavkat Mirziyoyev, President of Kyrgyzstan Sooronbai Jeenbekov paid an official visit to Uzbekistan on December 13-14. The parties have close views on many issues, and "this has never been a history of Kyrgyz-Uzbek relations,” President Mirziyoyev said after the talks.
NEW DELHI (TCA) — On December 3, Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani inaugurated the first phase of the Chabahar port development project on the Gulf of Oman, with the participation of senior Afghan and Indian ministers, including the Indian Minister for External Affairs Mrs. Sushma Swaraj.
BISHKEK (TCA) — As state power succession remains an issue for post-Soviet Central Asian republics, especially for Kazakhstan, we are republishing this article, originally published by Stratfor, that presents the political outlook for each of the region’s five countries:
LONDON (TCA) — It has been no one less than Kazakhstan’s head of state and veteran politician Nursultan Nazarbayev who was lately quoted by Tass as stating that “the re-emergence of terrorist cells following the heavy blow dealt to Islamic State in the Middle East is a serious challenge for Eurasian states. […] International terrorism has acquired a catastrophic scope, it has no borders. Any part of the globe can become a target for a disastrous onslaught."
BISHKEK (TCA) — All new railroads that cross Central Asia will eventually connect China to the wider region and Europe, and in this geostrategic railway game, Russia may find itself on the margins of the region’s railway map. We are republishing this article by Farkhad Sharip on the issue, originally published by The Jamestown Foundation’s Eurasia Daily Monitor:
NEW DELHI (TCA) — This week US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson paid a visit to South Asia. He visited both Islamabad and New Delhi, and made a sudden, secret visit to Afghanistan, too. So tight was the security that there is confusion over where exactly he had his meeting with Afghan President Ashraf Ghani – in Kabul or at the Bagram Air base, which he visited.
This was the first visit by Tillerson to the region since President Donald Trump unveiled his administration’s policy on South Asia and Afghanistan in August. A key component of this new Afghan policy is that he has changed the rules of military engagement. “A core pillar of our new strategy is a shift from a time-based approach to one based on conditions,” the President had announced. He has allowed the “integration of all diplomatic, economic, and military means” to target the enemy, without “micro-management from Washington”.
Trump has also called out Pakistan for its support in providing “safe-havens for terrorist organizations, the Taliban and other groups that pose a threat to the region and beyond.” This effectively means that US and NATO troops will be at liberty to pursue any action to target the Taliban, ISIS and any other terror group in Afghanistan.
Significantly, it has been reported that following his visit to Afghanistan, Tillerson has said there is a place for moderate elements of the Taliban in Afghanistan's government as long as they renounce violence and terrorism. This is not a new approach. Successive Afghan governments have tried to reach out to the Afghan Taliban. In an interview to this author, soon after a bloodbath by the Taliban on the streets of Kabul last year Afghan Ambassador to India Dr. Shaida Abdali had said “We do not see the ‘good’ or ‘bad’ Taliban. What we do see is the reconcilable and the irreconcilable Taliban.”
However, the Taliban insists on the departure of all foreign troops from Afghan soil before they agree to sit at the negotiating table, in spite of invitations to talks by powers like Russia and China. No doubt they feel emboldened to thus precondition talks, because of Pakistani support. Besides, the fractiousness of the coalition government in Kabul has contributed to the local support that the Taliban have managed to reclaim in many places because of abuses by representatives of the Afghan state or by those under its protection, like the local war lords. The Taliban today control almost forty per cent of Afghan territory.
This has made other regional players, including Russia and China, also reach out and open channels of communication with them. The Times earlier this month reported that it had learnt from members of the Taliban and Afghan officials that Russia is funding Taliban military operations against NATO in Afghanistan. The Russian Foreign Ministry has strongly repudiated that article saying “We believe that this fake, just as the other items containing false information, are aimed at drawing international attention away from the failure of NATO’s military policy in Afghanistan and are evidence of a resentful attitude to the stabilization efforts by Moscow and its regional partners … in Afghanistan.”
The ministry instead alleges that there are “…continued flights by unmarked helicopters to the Afghan regions controlled by extremists, whom British intelligence services are supporting.”
It is evident that Islamic State of Iraq and Syria militants have found a foothold in Afghanistan and there have been reports of Taliban and other militants moving over to their ranks. There is also worry in the region that with the current defeat of the ISIS in Iraq and Syria, its fighters may flock to Afghanistan where the country’s ungoverned tracts can offer them safe havens. To that end, Iran, whose longtime foe the Taliban has been, to also reach out to it, as it sees it as a lesser evil than ISIS and useful to counter the growth of ISIS there.
The Taliban has different factions and as the US steps up its military operations in Afghanistan, including with greater airpower, with no set deadline, even while the capability of the Afghan National Army is shored up, it is expected that the Taliban’s endurance will be tested and the more amenable factions may come forward to the negotiating table and eschew violence. Under sustained pressure from the US, Pakistan may not be able to keep up its support for the Afghan Taliban.
Pakistani analysts have decried Trump’s new Afghan policy as one which is bound to fail. Pakistan would like to have leverage over Kabul to maintain strategic depth against its arch-rival India on its eastern borders. However, Pakistan’s strategic location, for the movement of US troops and supplies into Afghanistan may not make it easy for the US to assert the kind of pressure it is threatening to. On the other hand, Pakistan’s close links with China can allow it to disdain US warnings.
Meanwhile, Iran, Russia, Pakistan would like to see US and NATO troops leave the region, even as the US becomes embroiled in this ‘new cold war’ with Russia while also alienating Iran with President Trump’s recent decertification of the Iran nuclear deal. It is a terribly complicated situation in which the worst brunt is borne by the Afghan people. It therefore becomes imperative for the government of President Ghani and CEO Abdullah to undertake reforms to provide better governance to the Afghan people. Afghans need to forge a national consciousness. Afghanistan is surviving on foreign aid today and in his speech formulating his Afghan policy, President Trump has also sent a veiled warning to the Afghan government, saying that “America will work with the Afghan government as long as we see determination and progress” and that American “commitment is not unlimited and our support is not a blank check”.
In spite of differences that persist within different stakeholders in Afghanistan and the different regional players, one thing is sure – an unstable Afghanistan is in no one’s interest. It is not only the neighboring and regional states, Pakistan included which embroiled in a war with its own local Pakistani Taliban, that are threatened by Afghan instability, as 9/11 has proved. It is time for all stakeholders to set aside their differences and work to find common ground there.
* Aditi Bhaduri is an independent journalist and political analyst specializing in international affairs and foreign policy. She writes for many national and international publications
LONDON (TCA) — Rather than what one might have expected, China’s regional and global aspirations were not on top of the agenda at the Communist Party congress which took place this past week. Instead, domestic affairs dominated the event in the form of a consolidation of the hierarchic political and governmental power structure amidst speculations about a possible change in the denomination of candidates for succession within the system’s top ranks. Whatever the case, the message to neighbouring countries and beyond was: China comes first, the rest of the world will come as well — but later.
LONDON (TCA) — It is a warm, sunny and lazy Sunday afternoon in the Kyrgyz capital and all is quiet. The ominous spectre of mass demonstrations, burning vehicles, charging security forces and shootouts invoked by western “revolution manufacturers” and mass media parroting them is as remote as remote could ever be. Kyrgyz people go or do not go to vote, with both categories expressing a pragmatic approach to politics: let things go on as they do, let leaders govern and leave business to the population. This overall attitude explains why hardly more than half of the voters bothered to vote in the first place.
OSH, Kyrgyzstan (TCA) — How far stretches the might of war profiteers in the global economy? Further than many people think, and Central Asia’s ex-Soviet republics bordering the world’s staunchest zone of large-scale bloodshed are particularly exposed to it.
LONDON (TCA) — Has Kyrgyzstan managed to accomplish what failed to happen in Russia and Kazakhstan (though both of them came close) – namely the position of a plutocracy under the guise of democracy, with the country’s rich having become powerful as well? For a country where up to one-third of the population still lives just on or way under the poverty line, this is bound to raise eyebrows. The worst thing is that those wielding the sceptre in a my-turn, your-turn sequence of top state functions, are not industrial barons who could lift the country’s economy up to better levels, but self-made tycoons feeding on largely speculative business.
Destination CIS: India looks to trade with Central Asia
Written by Aditi Bhaduri*
NEW DELHI (TCA) — How important the Central Asian Republics (CARs) are becoming to India was evident when a two-day long conference was held in the Indian capital New Delhi late in September to encourage trade and tourism with these countries. While titled ‘Destination CIS’, the emphasis was clearly on Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan, which were also the partner countries of the conference. Only one single session was devoted to business with the Russian region of Rostov. The rest of the sessions of the conference, which was the first of its kind, were focused on the CARs mentioned above. Turkmenistan did not participate.
With India’s efforts to increase exports and make the country a manufacturing hub with different schemes like Make in India, Skill India and others, increasingly new opportunities are being created for enhancing international economic cooperation. “At this juncture, where the traditional and the developed markets are getting saturated, it is essential for the developing economies to find ways to boost trade and investment between them. The CIS region, one of the fastest growing regions of the world, offers India tremendous opportunities across various sectors,” explained Mr. Niraj, who is Secretary, International Affairs, of the PHD Chamber of Commerce, which had organized the conference.
What made the conference particularly opportune was that this year also marks the 25th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between India and most of the CIS countries.
The CARs have had trade and cultural links with India going centuries back. The current government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi is keen to revive these links to the resource rich region, formulating the Connect Central Asia policy. To that end he has visited all the CARs, with Kazakhstan being the most recent destination. With an increasing Chinese footprint in the region – with $10 billion in grants and aid – India is also keen to seize the opportunities present there. Indian trade turnover with the region on the other hand is only about 2.5 billion dollars.
Four major areas with great potential for bilateral trade and cooperation that were identified were: food security in the CIS countries, promotion of two way tourism, finance and logistics, and promotion and delivery of affordable world class healthcare.
While India offers the CARs a huge market for their goods – mainly dry fruits, handicrafts, and tourists, particularly those looking for affordable but quality healthcare, the country is also interested in the minerals and hydrocarbons of the Central Asia region.
A major drawback for the country to strengthen and enhance ties with the region is connectivity. India has no direct access to the CARs, and any overland route has to go through Pakistan, its arch rival.
To that end India is pinning its hopes on the International North South Transport Corridor which is to link India via Iran and the Caspian Sea through a multi-modal transport system to Central Asia, and beyond to Astrakhan and Russia.
India is also looking into a free trade agreement with the Eurasian Economic Union which will significantly increase trade profitability.
At the same time, as Dr. Ram Upendra Das, Head and Professor for Centre for Regional Trade, Department of Commerce, the Indian Ministry of Commerce and Industry, pointed out, for most Indian businesses the CARs were an alien entity with many even unable to pronounce the names properly.
The conference was therefore an attempt to bridge the information gap and clear misconceptions about doing trade with the region.
As Ms. Samargul Adamkova pointed out, manufacturing in the Kyrgyz Republic, for instance, would instantly find a ready market of 183 million people in the Eurasian Economic Union member countries, thereby offering huge incentives for Indian investments.
A parallel exhibition showcasing the achievements, tourism industry and handicrafts of the region added to the knowledge about the CARs that the conference sought to disseminate.
* Aditi Bhaduri is an independent journalist and political analyst specializing in international affairs and foreign policy. She writes for many national and international publications
TASHKENT (TCA) — On his path to political and economic reforms, the new Uzbek president Mirziyoyev is facing many risks and challenges, and many of them are beyond his control which makes his task even more difficult. We are republishing this article on the issue, originally published by Stratfor:
ASTANA (TCA) — A giant globe flanked by a pair of hardly less modest looking humps on either side, surrounded by several blocks of square buildings on the desolate outskirts of Astana – itself not exactly an organic urban centre and in turn located in an endless barren environment. This is what is left of the complex hosting this year’s EXPO through summer. What to do with it next only exists on the minds of people in high places, and it remains unclear whether the structure can endure the region’s harsh winters when snow is man-high and temperatures are down to minus 20 during the day and minus 35 at night for half of the year.
BISHKEK (TCA) — Whenever you hear a country which ends in ‘Stan', you might associate things with war and terrorism. It might be the association with the situation in Afghanistan. But what is the life like in my home country, Kyrgyzstan, located just a bit over a 1,000 km to the northeast of Afghanistan?
Kyrgyzstan is the most democratic and one of the safe Central Asian countries so far. Despite Kyrgyzstan's lack of finance, the law enforcement bodies of the country are doing an excellent job combating terrorism, as they have thwarted all planned terrorist acts, Kadyr Malikov, the director of Kyrgyzstan’s analytical center Religion, Law and Politics, said in an emailed interview.
Malikov is the well-known Kyrgyz theologian who has always criticized fake religious supporters. He was attacked by IS supporters with a knife in November 2015. The attackers were arrested a few days after the attack, in Turkey, and extradited to Kyrgyzstan.
In late August 2017, during an anti-terrorist operation, the Kyrgyz National Security Committee liquidated an armed group who had planned terrorist attacks in Bishkek and the north of Kyrgyzstan.
In 2016, a car driven by a suicide bomber exploded after ramming the gates of the Chinese embassy in Kyrgyzstan. During the incident, three embassy security staff were injured. The incident was characterized as an attack by Xinjiang-linked Uighur extremists. Even though the incident was an action not directed at the crowd, it had alerted people from coming to Kyrgyzstan.
In 2015, a group of four who planned a terrorist act in the Russian air base in Kant, Kyrgyzstan and its surroundings were killed. Seven men were arrested. They all belonged to the Islamic State. During the special operation, four officers of the Kyrgyz National Security Committee were injured.
The Kyrgyz National Security Committee identified and liquidated 15 terrorist groups and 27 extremist religious groups in 2016. Last year, on 181 cases the criminal proceedings were instituted and 102 people received warnings from the Committee, Rahat Sulaymanov, the press secretary of the National Security Committee, said in an emailed interview.
The main reason for radicalization among the youth is social injustice, non-existence of social elevations, non-existence of self-realization and no opportunity to find a job, says Kadyr Malikov.
Things are changing
But the situation in Kyrgyzstan is slowly changing. There have been many programs within the last two decades offering scholarships to Kyrgyzstanis and citizens of other Central Asian countries to study overseas or improve their skills. Young people who have studied in the US, European, and Asian countries are returning back to Kyrgyzstan and fighting corruption. It is possible to see the job of many overseas graduates on social media. They are fighting corruption in the country by exposing particular cases on social media.
One of the examples is Aibek Baratov, a local social media activist who has dedicated himself to fighting injustice on the capital’s roads and combating corruption in the State Auto Inspection in Bishkek.
After graduating his school in the UK, he quickly became famous on social media for exposing officers of the State Auto Inspection for their wrongdoings and the drivers' bad behaviour as well. He also organizes fundraising to fix road signs in Bishkek.
Recently, Kyrgyz media reported that a graduate of Harvard University, Talant Sultanov, a graduate of Heidelberg University, Esenkul Momunkulov, and a current student of Oxford University have become Advisors to the new Prime Minister of Kyrgyzstan.
Education and society
There are Turkish and American universities in Bishkek offering bright and disadvantaged students good-quality free or discounted education. The Government is building better roads and hospitals. People who have studied or worked overseas are creating their new businesses such as new restaurants, schools, and shopping malls. By the way, eating in some new restaurants in Bishkek is more expensive than in European restaurants. Yet, they have found their customers who can afford eating in those venues.
More people in Kyrgyzstan now speak English and are active on social media. More people travel and can afford traveling overseas.
Even though there are yet many problems to be fixed like corruption in local universities, government structures, courts, and unemployment, my every visit back to Kyrgyzstan and the observation of Kyrgyzstan's life via social media show that the economy of Kyrgyzstan is improving. The National Security is doing its best to ensure the safety of the citizens and the country's future is being passed over from old Soviet-era thinkers to younger and brighter people.
* Zarina Satybaldieva is a TCA contributor, currently based in Australia
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author
NEW DELHI (TCA) — On September 17 Afghanistan President Ashraf Ghani emphasized the significance of the Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India (TAPI) gas pipeline, lauding the contribution that such large-scale projects could make to the peaceful settlement of the situation in Afghanistan and the sustainable social and economic development of the entire Central Asian region.
ASTANA (TCA) — Whatever the reasons for Kazakhstan’s planned transition to the Latin alphabet — from defining the nation’s identity to departing from the Imperial colonialism and Soviet-era dominance of the Russian language and Cyrillic alphabet — Kazakhstan has made the decision and the transition process is now irreversible. We are republishing this article by Uli Schamiloglu* on the issue, originally published by EurasiaNet.org:
TASHKENT (TCA) — During his first year in power, Uzbekistan’s President Mirziyaev has undertaken a number of reforms to open up his country to better relations with Central Asia neighbors and the international community. Although many of the reforms could be considered cosmetic, one thing is certain — Uzbekistan has begun to change and this change will benefit all countries in the region. We are republishing this article by Paul Goble on the issue, originally published by The Jamestown Foundation’s Eurasia Daily Monitor:
LONDON (TCA) — In Central Asia job supplies do not match job demand since governments and their investment policy do not offer the required political stability and sufficient incentives to attract local and foreign investors. This simply means that migration of Kyrgyz, Tajik and Uzbek working forces toward Russia and in less number other countries is here to stay for quite a while.